Sunday, December 05, 2004

What is the Purpose/Function of the Christian Media?

Obviously, there's never been in the history of the world the world as it is today. I think that Christians, in every era, are presented with unique challenges.

In our country, it is the media's job to uncover truth, and there never seems to be a shortage of it to uncover. A good example of this is recent work the San Franciso Tribune has done in the Barry Bonds doping case. It's not nice to expose baseball players for their misdeeds, and the reporters even went so far as to report testimony they had procured via a leak that was not supposed to be public information. The media seems to be one of the checks and balances in our democracy, really they seem like a form of accountability for anyone who is involved in anything nefarious enough to be scandalous.

But there's that word: scandal. It's a fine line between hard investigation and digging for dirt. I mean, what's really the difference between uncovering a sex scandal involving the president or one involving a movie star?

Ah, but what about the Christian media? Like it or not (and I don't think I do), Christian institutions--particularly music, but really any large-scale ministry--are modeled after our society in that they play to the big-names. Within the parameters of the Christian Contemporary Music industry, for instance, the market is driven by specific artists. Billy Graham, Ken Ham, Bill Gothard. You go to a concert because of the name, you follow the groups, you follow the singers, you wait and snatch up new albums from your favorites, you go to a seminar because of a name. While I hope it stops short of hero worship (a sermon tonight was called "No Other Gods"), for better or for worse "common" people latch onto those who can make their spines tingle via their vocals or their playing or their preaching and this creates a culture in which these special people held up.

Now they're public figures, recognized by fans of theirs. Now media springs up to support these industry. You have CCM magazine, the Singing News, Christianity Today, etc. Now, with the internet, people from across the country and world anonymously discuss their favorites, and blogs give opinion and analysis.

But should the Christian media function as the secular one does? Scripture surely doesn't address this specifically. Perhaps it does in principle, though. If something is wrong in a large "ministry" or with a Christian performer, should they be held publicly accountable? Should they be called out?

See, all this grows out of this celebritizing of Christianity. I don't know how we can get around it, but I don't know if it's right.

But if a "minister" is a celebrity, and living sinfully, for instance, something needs to be done. I mean, the media's just searching for the truth, right? They just want transparency, supposedly. And those things are good. So ... what?

6 Comments:

At 9:46 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You have some good thoughts here. But what is the difference between being a Christian leader and being a Christian celebrity? -Marcel

 
At 4:02 PM, Blogger Byran said...

I don't know if there is a difference, at least in the way I framed it (which may not be correct). The way I see it, the Apostle Paul would have been a huge celebrity in his day. The difference is, there was no hounding Christian media or blogger types that were analyzing his life and fruits.

 
At 10:28 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The media, hold celebrities accountable? I see the media as more trying to find dirt because that's what the people want to see and hear about. For some reason it seems the human nature in people delights in seeing another do something wrong. I don't know why... Maybe because it makes us feel better when we here of someone doing something horrific that "we would never do". It seems to me that today's media is also rather biased in their scandels. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it almost seems to me that most of todays news (esp.television news) is given more to increase their viewing audiences then to speak truth. Yes, we as Christians need to hold each other accountable, in love and for love, to draw othes into a closer relationship with our Lord, not to slaughter them, and spread their misdeeds. Now, I don't want to put all the secular media in one group, I am sure, or I hope :) their are some that wish to let the truth be known. I think personally that there should be a big difference between the Christian media and the secular media. Now as far as recognizing Christian "celebrities" what about the testimony of someone really making a difference, and being radically on fire for God being applauded and encouraged. Shouldn't we also encourage others with their testimonies. I guess it comes down to what we are applauding, how beautiful they look and sing, how well they speak, or how they follow Jesus. As Paul said "Follow me as I follow Christ." I bet we will be surprised in heaven who the real "celebrities" end up being.
La

 
At 7:54 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

La, you "took the words right out of my mouth." Motive is a major factor here. Truth is NOT necessarily the aim of the media. Promoting their worldview is the aim. That strongly dictates what they expose, what they promote and how they present their "facts." Sadly, too much of Christianity today has embraced a wrong worldview and isn't aware of it; altho, there are those who are giving us a strong wake-up call.

Merry

 
At 8:41 PM, Blogger Byran said...

I'm pretty sure that there are many in journalism whose aim it is to report the facts. That's their job, and I don't believe there's a huge conspiracy to taint the facts with the liberal worldview that the majority of journalists have. But there is bias at times.

That being said, the point of my post was to think about whether "Christian" media should have the same professed goals as the secular media, i.e. finding and exposing the truth that is in the public interest (which would exclude sensationalism, but might include that at times as a necessary result of informing the public).

 
At 12:11 PM, Blogger M. Joseph said...

Thank you very much for the mentions of ChristianityToday.com from your blog. We greatly appreciate the promotion of our content to your audience.

Whether you agree or disagree with our views from one article to the next, we desire to encourage discussion on the topics we cover. Mentions in blogs such as yours helps us accomplish this goal.

Please contact me if I can be of any assistance to you in the future.


Sincerely,

michael.herman
mherman@christianitytoday.com
Online Promotion Manager
http://ChristianityToday.com
Christianity Today International

 

Post a Comment

<< Home